Tuesday, September 22, 2026

Battle Ground Schools

 The first spot I really paused is when this text compared the approach we take while teaching mathematics to the blind obedience to authority and lack of independence of mind that run rampant in the face of fascism. This really made me think of how the way we teach math can impact students and their broader social values. We want everyone in society to be able to think for themselves, to form their own thoughts, create their own art, and come to their own conclusions. If we center math around simply memorizing and regurgitating an algorithm, we are reinforcing the digestion of information without questioning it. Students and individuals in general should be able to look at concepts, dissect flaws, and learn to apply them to different situations. These are skills we want people to have so it would make sense to ensure students develop them across all educational disciplines for a more comprehensive education. 


The “New Math” section as a whole made me question its validity as an approach in the first place. I feel as if a curriculum designed out of a desire to outcompete another country cannot truly be focused on optimizing student learning. I feel as if pumping K-12 full of abstract material and difficult concepts university students tend to tackle is the equivalent of getting students to just regurgitate information without a solid understanding. If anything, I feel like it’s more important to tackle basic concepts and ensure students can apply them to numerous situations and contexts. Although this method did value understanding over literacy, its main purpose was to pump out a few top-notch students from high schools while leaving everyone else behind. A teaching philosophy based on competition focuses on the wrong topics. K-12 should be more about building problem-solving skills and critical thinking rather than introducing students to every topic they may encounter further on in their education. 


Finally, I don’t think I’ve considered math in relation to politics, but it makes a lot of sense when pointed out. Individuals often get stuck on “math is math”; it can’t change, so why are we changing the curriculum or how we teach it? Once again, I believe this stems from a prevailing belief that math is all about algorithms and memorizing how to get to an answer. When you take a second and ask why, it opens up a lot more discussion and possibilities. However, the general public may see this as an “attack” on science because it's not the way they learnt things. I feel like, in this day and age, we need to understand that just because that is how something has always been done, it doesn’t mean it's right. There is always opposition to change, even in math, and I find it quite interesting that the way in which we have taught math throughout the years coincides with the current political state of the world.


1 comment:

  1. Jackie, your connection between the way we teach mathematics and the broader goal of developing students who can think independently and question what they are given really stood out to me. How might we design mathematics learning so that students are not only learning to solve problems, but also developing the confidence to question the mathematics itself?

    ReplyDelete

MoMath

MoMath is the award-winning National Museum of Mathematics located in New York City. It specializes in illuminating math through art and vis...